Roskomnadzor compared Beeline, MTS and Megafon in terms of quality of work. The most economical tariffs of Beeline, MTS and Megafon

We all use a mobile phone every day to talk, send SMS and access the Internet. At the same time, there is a natural desire to reduce expenses and not worry about the balance of funds in the account. And the main thing is that this does not come at the expense of quality. For this purpose, there are unlimited tariffs offered on our website. Let's compare two tariffs that are intended for local calls in Moscow and the Moscow region: In touch. Moscow 1170 from Beeline and Exclusive M 1200 from Megafon.

Pros and cons of calling tariffs

Unlimited mobile packages provide, although a large, but still limited number of free minutes for outgoing calls. Therefore, if you often talk a lot on the phone, then pay special attention to this criterion. Operators allocate the following amounts per month:

Beeline - 7200 minutes;
Megaphone - 4000 minutes.

These free minutes can be used for both local calls and long-distance calls from Moscow. The Beeline tariff for Moscow and the Moscow region has a significantly larger number. However, if you often make local calls to Megafon numbers, then the difference in limits will be almost invisible. After all, local on-net calls from Megafon remain free even after the limit has been exhausted. Beeline does not provide such an option. Calls within Russia above the limit cost almost the same - 3 rubles for Beeline and 2.9 rubles for Megafon.

Cost of SMS, MMS and Internet

SMS messaging has become one of the most widely used methods of communication today. If this is an important part of life for you, then Beeline will delight you with a large number of free SMS - 200 per day to any numbers in Russia. As part of the Megafon package, free messages are also provided, but their number is less - 50 per day, and they can only be used to send SMS to numbers in Moscow and the Moscow region. And for messages sent to other numbers in the country you will have to pay 2.9 rubles.

With MMS, things are exactly the same as with text messages. Beeline generously gives out 200 free MMS per day for sending throughout the country, and Megafon - 50 for Moscow. For the latter, the cost of MMS in Russia is 6 rubles.

Thus, in terms of the benefits of communicating via messages, Beeline seriously outperforms Megafon. But the volume of free Internet for both operators is absolutely the same - 5 GB per month. This is a decent amount, which is more than enough for basic tasks performed using a mobile phone - checking email, correspondence on social networks, searching for the necessary information, etc.

International outgoing calls

Calls to CIS countries will cost less in the Beeline tariff, since the first 10 minutes of communication will cost 3 rubles per minute, and then 24 rubles. Megafon charges 20 rubles from the first minute. Therefore, Megafon will be more profitable only if you plan to talk to numbers from the CIS for more than an hour a day.

But it’s cheaper to call Europe, the USA and Canada with Megafon - 30 rubles versus 35 rubles per minute with Beeline

Which tariff is better?

There is no clear answer, and in many ways the tariffs are equal. Beeline wins if you actively use SMS messages and make a lot of calls to numbers that do not belong to network subscribers. A small pleasant plus of Beeline is that the monthly subscription fee is 30 rubles less than Megafon. Megafon wins back a little ground in the case of a large number of intranet communications and calls to Europe.

By choosing and ordering the most favorable tariff from us, you will receive fast delivery in Moscow, prompt support and a discount when ordering a second issue.

Comparing operators is a very difficult matter, since there are quite a few key factors in this process. However, subscribers are often puzzled by finding a solution to this problem. In this review we will look at Beeline or MegaFon - which is better and which of these operators to give your preference. Choosing the right option is really difficult, but we will try to find the most optimal solution.

Select by coverage area

Let's see which connection is better - MegaFon or Beeline. To begin with, you should clarify whether there is a signal from these operators in those points where you visit most often. For example, at work, at the dacha, at your favorite vacation spot. There are places where only one operator is caught or the most needed one is missing - there are all sorts of situations.

There are two ways to check the availability of coverage area:

By calling the Beeline or MegaFon help desk;
Visit the official websites to view the broadcast area;
Conduct a practical experiment (will give the most accurate results).

In urban areas, determining who is better is problematic, since all operators strive to provide the most complete coverage. But outside the city, flaws emerge - in some places only Beeline is received, and in others only MegaFon is received. You can arm yourself with a phone with both SIM cards and do a comparative analysis.

Choice by tariffs

MegaFon or Beeline - which is better, where are the better tariffs, what should you give preference to? There are many questions, and even more answers. Both operators are ready to offer their subscribers a variety of tariff plans with different content.

Here's what you need to look for when choosing a tariff:

The amount of the subscription fee;
The cost of calls to subscribers of other operators;
For intercity costs;
For the number of included services;
For the cost of services outside the included packages.

Typically, operators offer the most favorable rates only for on-net calls - many tariffs provide excellent on-network unlimited limits. But in the question of which is better, other packages should be evaluated.

For example, at Beeline we can find tariffs for pensioners or tariffs with per-second billing that many subscribers need. And MegaFon pleases its customers with the availability of a whole group of tariff plans for visitors and travelers.

Selection by Internet services

Let's see which Internet is better - MegaFon or Beeline. What is important here is not so much the cost of modems, but the cost of services. For example, MegaFon has the following lucrative offers:

36 GB for 890 rub./month;
30 GB during the day and unlimited at night for 1,290 rubles/month;
20 GB of traffic, additional traffic for music, social networks and instant messengers, unlimited SMS and 5,000 minutes within Russia for 3,000 rubles/month.

The latest offering is aimed at accessing the Internet from a smartphone while simultaneously using calls and text messages.

Great offers from Beeline for smartphones:

“All 5” tariff, including 15 GB of regular traffic, unlimited social networks, 5000 minutes and 500 SMS for 83.3 rubles/day;
Tariff “Everything for 1800 postpaid” with 30 GB of traffic, 3000 SMS and 3300 minutes for 1800 rubles/month;
“Absolutely EVERYTHING” tariff with a 60 GB package and premium roaming tariffs for 6,000 rubles/month.

For modems, the most profitable tariff is “Internet for a computer” - 25 GB for 1200 rubles / month. Starting from the second month of use, the amount of traffic doubles.

You can argue for a long time which modem is better - MegaFon or Beeline. But here it all comes down to the availability of a coverage area at the point you need and the content of the traffic packets. The best modem is one that provides maximum speed and stable communication.. We also recommend taking a look at the coverage areas of MegaFon and Beeline to compare coverage areas in 3G and 4G format.

Selection by contacts

If you have doubts about your choice and you don’t know what is best to choose, we recommend that you look in your phone book. Here you should estimate the number of MegaFon and Beeline subscribers. Based on this, It’s better to choose the operator whose subscribers you have in your phone book. If everyone around you uses Beeline services, feel free to purchase a SIM card from a black and yellow operator. Otherwise, it is better to choose a MegaFon SIM card.

Switch between operators with your own number

If you couldn’t decide which is better, MegaFon or Beeline, you can purchase any SIM card - subsequently you will have the opportunity to migrate from Beeline to MegaFon and back without losing your number. The transition process is quite lengthy, but it allows you to get rid of changing the number and the subsequent difficulties (you will not need to notify your interlocutors about the change of number).

The question of which is better, Beeline or MegaFon, may be removed from the agenda if you buy a phone with support for two SIM cards. In this case, you can quickly test the capabilities of operators and choose the option you like best.

114 users find this page useful.

Quick answer:
Comparative characteristics:
Advantages of Beeline:

regular competitions and promotions;

From shortcomings– rare operational problems associated with hardware updates.

Advantages of MTS:

a large number of bonuses.

Negative properties of MTS:

When choosing a SIM card, everyone is faced with the question of which operator to choose so that it is comfortable to use its services without overpaying. The most common dilemma is “Beeline or MTS”? Since these companies are the undisputed leaders in the Russian Federation, and are also found in some other countries.

To fully answer the question of which is better - Beeline or MTS, it is necessary to clarify by what characteristic the assessment should be made. It is advisable to use the following parameters:

Cost of calls and messages.
Mobile Internet.
Overall call quality.

It is advisable to take into account all the nuances together before purchasing a SIM card in order to avoid possible problems. However, do not be upset, since both of the operators in question have the option of switching to their company while maintaining your current number, which is very convenient.

Which operator is more suitable for communication?

The range of tariffs and services for both companies is approximately the same. Despite the fact that each region has its own peculiarities in tariff plans, payments for roaming, outgoing calls and SMS messages are practically at the same level.

Beeline

Internet speed comparison

Beeline is a company that appeared in 1993 and currently has more than 60 million subscribers. Main advantages:

a huge range of options, convenient and profitable tariff plans;
regular competitions and promotions;
the operator constantly improves the quality of communications and services, increases Internet speed, updates equipment and increases the coverage area, which makes the network more accessible;
The service center employs impeccably polite professionals who competently answer all questions that arise.

Among the shortcomings are rare malfunctions associated with updating the equipment.

MTS

MTS is a multimillion-dollar peer of VimpelCom, providing a decent level of communication quality. It has a large number of different tariffs and services.

Main advantages:

almost uninterrupted operation throughout the entire coverage area;
frequent competitions, interesting promotions;
a large number of bonuses.

Negative properties:

the company is more inclined to connect paid options without the subscriber’s knowledge or transfer free services to the category of paid ones;
prices for some options are higher than those of Beeline;
the coverage area is smaller, that is, communication is not available in all parts of our vast country;
the need for a long wait for a response from technical support, the average level of competence of employees, the high cost of services when connecting them by calling the Contact Center.

Important: when choosing a SIM card and tariff for communication, you should take into account the characteristics of the region where the user lives, the presence or absence of the need for calls outside of it and to numbers of other operators, and the cost of these calls.

Which provider is better

Internet usage comparison chart

Internet on a mobile device.
Internet on a tablet is similar to the first type, but differs in tariff schedule and functionality; usually more “resource-intensive” tariffs are connected here, allowing you to watch videos, use online applications, and games.
For a modem - suitable for areas where the Internet has not yet been installed or where it has low speed and quality. This is especially true for small provincial towns, villages and hamlets.

According to statistical surveys, Beeline is in slightly greater demand. This is not only a well-developed mobile network, but also a good provider.

Mobile Internet

Internet from Beeline has a number of advantages:

High speed.
Low number of problems.
Reasonable prices.

Among the shortcomings, we can note periodic “freezes” in the cheapest tariffs.

Access to the network from MTS is characterized by a high-speed transmission stream, but due to the smaller coverage area, the Internet does not work harmoniously everywhere. Many users note a decrease in speed underground, during rush hour, and simply when watching a video.

Internet on tablet

Both companies have developed specialized tariffs for tablet Internet.

Beeline offers such convenient and advantageous tariffs as “Internet Forever”, “Simple Internet”, which allow you to fully use the tablet - communicate on social networks and conduct video conversations, read online books, view websites, GIF images, watch videos.
MTS has developed a line of slightly more expensive tariffs for tablet devices - Mini, Maxi, Vip, which, given the smaller network coverage area, makes the company inferior to VimpelCom.

Both systems have tariff modifications, additional options for extending megabyte sizes or data transfer speeds.

Selecting an operator for the modem

Many people are interested in which modem should be chosen. Based on the above data, it is advisable to prefer a device from Beeline or use a SIM card from this company to connect. It is better to use them as a modem than MTS, since they provide high Internet speed at an affordable price.

For information: when choosing a company, it is advisable to take into account several parameters at once, since usually a SIM card is purchased simultaneously for calls, communication via SMS and Internet sessions.

Quality of service

Tariff comparison

The level of quality of service in Technical Support is higher in Beeline, which is proven by the manager’s quick response, his good communication skills, and the excellent competence of his employees. At MTS, sometimes you have to call the Service Center several times before a specialist comes on line.

Both companies offer their clients personal account services on official websites, as well as specialized applications for smartphones with a convenient, understandable and dynamic interface. An additional advantage of using your Personal Account is the ability to connect a number of services for free, their large range and the presence of a filter, the option to view call details and debit funds from your personal account.

When choosing an operator for mobile communications, many Russian residents are faced with a dilemma, and many ask the question: which is better - MTS or MegaFon. It is also worth noting that the Beeline operator is also quite popular in the Russian telecommunications services market. A mobile phone has become an integral part of the lives of many people, because thanks to this device you can keep in touch with business partners and relatives, as well as use the Internet to access various sites and programs.

Which connection is better: MTS or MegaFon

When choosing a card for your gadget, you should take into account what the device will be used for. It is worth determining which connection is better: MTS or MegaFon, Beeline, based on your own expectations from the chosen tariff, since they have quite different conditions. For tablets, it is better to choose operators that specifically provide Internet traffic, since regular tariffs from mobile communication leaders may not meet consumer needs. If a package is purchased for a phone, then you should start from the number of calls (international, regional, etc.), the number of SMS, as well as the traffic consumed.

All Russian operators (MegaFon, Beeline, etc.) offer their customers modems into which they can insert a company card and use prepaid traffic anywhere in the country with a good level of coverage. Many subscribers are interested in whether it is possible to use a MegaFon modem for an MTS card, and experts note that the device will not function (work is possible only after reflashing the modem).

MegaFon vs MTS – users' choice

Considering that there are many subscribers in the country, their choice falls on MTS, Beeline, and MegaFon. However, often the acquisition of a package of a particular operator occurs spontaneously, without studying the conditions. Only after a certain period of using the card does a person want to purchase a modem or connect additional functions to his number. Operator MegaFon versus MTS is healthy competition with many satisfied subscribers on both sides. Having created a special survey, experts highlighted the features of the three main operators in the Russian space: MegaFon, Beeline and MTS.

Megaphone. This operator has the following positive features:

many base stations providing good coverage even to the most remote corners of the country;
active implementation of advanced technologies in the operation of the mobile network;
adequate cost of services and related products (modems, applications, etc.).

Having posed the question on some forums: MTS or MegaFon (2017), many subscribers responded that it was the large coverage area that became the impetus for purchasing a MegaFon operator card.

Beeline. This popular operator has the following advantages:

a wide variety of tariffs and additional services (routers, modems, etc.);
Beeline is famous for its promotional programs for subscribers;
competent specialists of the Beeline support center.

MTS. This successful company stands out for the following features:

use of modern equipment to improve communication quality;
interesting tariff plans;
many related products (applications, modems, routers, etc.).

Users also noticed that some operators have a number of small disadvantages, which include: periodic problems in the contact center, unfavorable roaming conditions, as well as the considerable cost of modems, tariff plans and additional services.

Hi all!

I rarely write reviews about telecom operators, but sometimes I really want to pour out my soul to someone and tell them what I have accumulated. This is why I want to tell you about my unsuccessful connection to the Beeline network. Maybe my review will be useful to at least someone and I will be glad if I saved someone from unnecessary negativity that can fall on your head if you connect to Beeline. Of course, I speak specifically for my situation and express MY opinion on this matter, but at the same time I admit the idea that someone liked this connection and there were no problems. In general, no cellular connection is absolutely ideal, but some are simply amazing in their arrogance, and it is precisely this attitude towards the client that I want to complain about in today’s review.

Why did I decide to try this connection?

Let me start by saying that I have a dual-SIM phone. One of the SIM cards is Tele 2, and I decided to buy the second one from Beeline, since I was very attracted to one of the tariffs on this operator. At that moment it seemed to me that I was unlikely to return to the previous network, because the All Inclusive tariff was so tempting and cool. Yeah... exactly until you run into him. Now I regretted that the idea of buying this SIM card and connecting an expensive tariff to it immediately came into my head. It was necessary to start with something simpler and only then, if you liked everything, install something cooler.

So, what do I expect from the connection: good conversations without network interruption and fast Internet.

Based on my requirements, I chose the PossibleEverything tariff plan. Since I use the Internet every day and 5 GB for a month was never enough for me, I decided to take the option with unlimited Internet so that I could listen to music on VKontakte, look at photos and the like at any time. I have 3 social networks and I want to spend time on each for at least an hour a day. As for me, an hour of Internet use per day is a minuscule amount.

I always use the Internet only from my computer, so I only needed the Internet for social networks.

I don’t talk on the phone that often, but I get 3 calls a day, lasting about 5 minutes maximum.

The service package of my tariff includes 300 minutes, 300 SMS and unlimited Internet. For all this pleasure I paid 300 rubles (monthly subscription fee).

I also think it is necessary to clarify that before this I had always used the Tele 2 Internet and was happy with everything, but 5 gigs from that connection was not enough for me and I decided not to waste time on trifles and connect to Beeline’s unlimited service, because the price is not so exorbitant.

What did I get?

Internet epic

I bought myself a Beeline SIM card, consultants in one of the stores connected me to the required tariff. For some reason unknown to me, it took 40 minutes, or even more. I don’t understand why they work at such mega speed. There were only two visitors, me and another man, who was silent for a long time and waited for the 3, Karl, consultants who connected me to my tariff plan to be free. In the end, I survived to the bitter end (well, what else could I do), and that man said that he would not come to them again, since the speed of their service was simply unrealistic.

Well, in general, I’m used to the fact that in our communication stores they serve at the speed of light, so we can say that I didn’t pay much attention to this, but took it for granted, because in our city I rarely saw a different attitude towards clients.

Well, finally I got the tariff I’ve been dreaming about for so long!

I came home joyful with the hope that now I can calmly surf the Internet while lying in my crib. But no! The Internet simply refused to work on my phone. It took so long to load one VKontakte message, as if they had sent me a whole movie and told me to watch it from my phone. After my vain attempts to access the simplest sites like mail, the Internet completely disappeared and never appeared again

This didn’t suit me and the next day I went to a cell phone store, it wasn’t in vain that I paid the money... As usual, there were no big queues there and I asked one of the consultants for help and explained what didn’t suit me and asked why it was may be related.

The young man swapped the SIM cards (moved them from one slot to another), as you remember, I also have a SIM card on the phone 2. After that, he began to try to access the Internet.

Nothing has changed. After that, he continued to twirl my phone in his hands for about 20 minutes (at times, of course, distracted by vital conversations with his work friends). After all his supposed attempts, he asked me how to access the Internet settings, I showed him and he did what I had already tried to do without his help. In the end, he got tired of it and said that my phone was too old and there was no Internet at all on this model! Bravo! At parting, he shouted in my back that only in their salon I have a unique opportunity to buy a cell phone from 3,900 rubles and this is my chance. In response to my explanation and arguments that everything works perfectly on SIM card 2 on the same phone, he again only repeated his previous phrase that there is no Internet on such phones anymore. By the way, I bought the phone for 9,000 rubles, it’s not some kind of push-button phone. Although, by the way, I have also come across push-button phone models that have an Internet function and it loads there very quickly.

After this wonderful visit to the consultants, I came home and changed my SIM cards back to the position they were before and hallelujah! The Internet began to quickly load everything I needed. I already decided that now Beeline will be my favorite cellular connection forever and ever and even harmful consultants will not separate us. But my dreams didn’t last long and I realized that I couldn’t get this connection almost anywhere (while the other SIM card always worked without failures). The phone loaded the Internet on Beeline more or less tolerably only when I was at home (although I already have the opportunity to surf the Internet from a computer). If I went outside, it became unrealistic to go online, I was stuck - the result was the same. And only at home the Internet began to load, and then every day it got slower and slower.

This is where my attempts to make friends with Beeline ended. No more Megaphone(who at one time withdrew money from my account just like that), I definitely won’t switch to Beeline. I've had enough experimentation.

I'd rather continue to use my Tele 2.

Communication during telephone calls

There were never any complaints here, although at times the connection still disappeared for no apparent reason. But the conversation never stopped.

Money was withdrawn from the tariff every day, and not so once a month I put it in and it was immediately withdrawn.

I also want to tell you about how Beeline “pleased” my loved one not so long ago.

It was just that day when at my work (that is, outside the house) the Internet refused to load, and I really wanted to watch a video on the Internet. And then, by misfortune, my brother and I went online from his phone (for the first time in 5 years, since the Internet is not needed there at all) and watched one single video lasting a minute. After that, a bunch of messages fell on that phone saying that “now we have connected you to a wonderful feature and you can spend 1.5 GB every day and you will be charged a subscription fee of 7 rubles/day.”

To say that we were shocked is to say nothing. A person doesn’t see any point in surfing the Internet at all, and so one day he decided to watch a short video, and he was already connected to functions (Huawei 1.5 GB) that he had absolutely no use for. But no! They didn’t even bother to clarify whether he needed it? They simply presented the fact that now money will be withdrawn every day. It would be okay if he were simply offered to use such a service, but to connect right away? This is already impudence!

After that, he and I went online to look for information about what combination of numbers needed to be dialed to turn off this tariff. We found how Huawei turns off at 1 GB, 3 GB, 5 GB and then in ascending order. Not a word about 1.5 GB anywhere! As a result, I had to go into my personal account and disable this unnecessary function myself, since I had no desire to go to the salon again.

No, no and no again! Those who need the Internet on their phone at amazing speeds are unlikely to appreciate this connection.

For those who need a phone only for conversations, this network may be suitable, but on the condition that you will never access the Internet even for a minute, otherwise you will be connected to a bunch of functions unknown to the world, which then will not be so easy to disable.

I give Beeline 2 stars, and even then it’s a stretch. For me, this network turned out to be a failure and I will never return to it.